EN BANC
[G.R. No. 2586. January 19, 1906. ]
TOMAS GUISON, Petitioner-Appellant, v. MARIA CONCEPCION, Respondent.
Teodoro Gonzalez, for Appellant.
Gabriel & Borbon, for Appellee.
SYLLABUS
1. WILLS; INABILITY TO SIGN; SIGNATURE BY ANOTHER. — The testatrix was not able to sign her name to the will, and she requested another person to sign it for her. Instead of writing her name he wrote his own upon the will. Held, That the will was not duly executed. (Following Ex No. 2002, August 18, 1905.)
D E C I S I O N
WILLARD, J.:
Jacoba Concepcion Salcedo made her will in Manila, on January 3, 1904. The last part of the will is as follows:jgc:chanrobles.com.ph
"Asi lo otorgo ante los testigos Señores Ambrosio Reyes, Mariano de Leon y Felix Polintan, de Manila, Islas Filipinas, y por no yo poder firmar, firma a mi ruego el mismo Feliciano Maglaqui, en mi presencia y de los mencionados testigos, quienes tambien suscriben, cada uno de ellos en presencia de los otros y la mia.
"(Firmado) FELICIANO MAGLAQUI.
"(Firmado) AMBROSIO REYES.
"(Firmado) MARIANO DE LEON.
"(Firmado) FELIX POLINTAN.
"Nosotros Ambrosio Reyes, Mariano de Leon y Felix Polintan, atestiguamos que Filiciano Maglaqui, a ruego de la Sra. Jacoba Concepcion Salcedo y en presencia de la misma y la nuestra, firmo el testamento que antecede; y que cada uno de nosotros lo firmo en presencia de los otros y de dicha testadora.
"Manila, tres de Enero de mil novecientos cuatro.
"(Firmado) AMBROSIO REYES.
"(Firmado) MARIANO DE LEON.
"(Firmado) FELIX POLINTAN."cralaw virtua1aw library
It will be seen that the witness Feliciano Maglaqui, instead of writing the name of the testatrix on the will, wrote his own. Probate of the will was refused in the court below on the ground that the name of the testatrix was not signed thereto, and the petitioner has appealed. The question presented has been decided adversely to the appellant in the following cases: Ex parte Pedro Arcenas Et. Al., 1 No. 1708, August 24, 1905 (4 Off. Gaz., 568); Ex parte Nemesio Delfin Santiago, 2 No. 2002, August 18, 1905 (4 Off. Gaz., 507.)
The judgment of the court below is affirmed, with the costs of this instance against the appellant, and after the expiration of twenty days judgment should be entered in accordance herewith and the case remanded to the court below for execution. So ordered.
Arellano, C.J., Mapa, Johnson and Carson, JJ., concur.
"Asi lo otorgo ante los testigos Señores Ambrosio Reyes, Mariano de Leon y Felix Polintan, de Manila, Islas Filipinas, y por no yo poder firmar, firma a mi ruego el mismo Feliciano Maglaqui, en mi presencia y de los mencionados testigos, quienes tambien suscriben, cada uno de ellos en presencia de los otros y la mia.
"(Firmado) FELICIANO MAGLAQUI.
"(Firmado) AMBROSIO REYES.
"(Firmado) MARIANO DE LEON.
"(Firmado) FELIX POLINTAN.
"Nosotros Ambrosio Reyes, Mariano de Leon y Felix Polintan, atestiguamos que Filiciano Maglaqui, a ruego de la Sra. Jacoba Concepcion Salcedo y en presencia de la misma y la nuestra, firmo el testamento que antecede; y que cada uno de nosotros lo firmo en presencia de los otros y de dicha testadora.
"Manila, tres de Enero de mil novecientos cuatro.
"(Firmado) AMBROSIO REYES.
"(Firmado) MARIANO DE LEON.
"(Firmado) FELIX POLINTAN."cralaw virtua1aw library
It will be seen that the witness Feliciano Maglaqui, instead of writing the name of the testatrix on the will, wrote his own. Probate of the will was refused in the court below on the ground that the name of the testatrix was not signed thereto, and the petitioner has appealed. The question presented has been decided adversely to the appellant in the following cases: Ex parte Pedro Arcenas Et. Al., 1 No. 1708, August 24, 1905 (4 Off. Gaz., 568); Ex parte Nemesio Delfin Santiago, 2 No. 2002, August 18, 1905 (4 Off. Gaz., 507.)
The judgment of the court below is affirmed, with the costs of this instance against the appellant, and after the expiration of twenty days judgment should be entered in accordance herewith and the case remanded to the court below for execution. So ordered.
Arellano, C.J., Mapa, Johnson and Carson, JJ., concur.
Endnotes:
1. 4 Phil. Rep., 700.
2. 4 Phil. Rep., 692.
