Home of ChanRobles Virtual Law Library

PHILIPPINE SUPREME COURT DECISIONS

EN BANC

[G.R. No. 31732. February 19, 1930. ]

Estate of the deceased Gregorio Pueblo. CARMEN QUINTO, Applicant-Appellant, v. MARGARITA MORATA, in substitution of Mateo Pueblo, deceased, contestant-appellee.

Guevara, Francisco & Recto, for Appellant.

Augusto de la Rosa and Angel Arigo, for Appellee.

SYLLABUS


1. WILLS; ATTESTATION CLAUSE, EVIDENCE TO SUPPLY DEFECTS OF. — The attestation clause must be made in strict conformity with the requirements of section 618 of Act No. 190, as amended. Where said clause fails to show on its face a full compliance with those requirements, the defect constitutes sufficient ground for the disallowance of the will. (Saño v. Quintana, 48 Phil., 506; Gumban v. Gorecho, 50 Phil., 30.) Evidence aliunde should not be admitted to establish facts not appearing on the attestation clause, and where said evidence has been admitted it should not be given the effect intended. (Uy Coque v. Navas L. Sioca, 43 Phil., 405, 409.)

2. ID.; ID.; INTERPRETATION OF SECTION 618 OF ACT NO. 190, AS AMENDED. — Section 618 of Act No. 190, as amended, should be given a strict interpretation in order to give effect to the intention of the Legislature. Statutes prescribing formalities to be observed in the execution of wills are very strictly construed. Courts cannot supply the defective execution of a will. (40 Cyc., p. 1079; Uy Coque v. Navas L. Sioca, supra.)


D E C I S I O N


JOHNSON, J.:


This is an appeal from a decision of the Honorable Manuel V. Moran, judge of the Court of First Instance of Cavite, denying the application of Carmen Quinto for the probate of the alleged will of the deceased Gregorio Pueblo, her husband.

The application for probate was filed on October 26, 1928 by Carmen Quinto, executrix of said will. It was a joint and mutual will of Gregorio Pueblo and his said wife Carmen Quinto and contained a provision that the surviving spouse shall take charge of the properties therein described and that they shall pass to the heirs and legatees at the time of the death of the surviving spouse.

To said application an opposition was filed by Mateo Pueblo, a brother of the deceased, on the following grounds: (1) That the attestation clause of said will does not state the number of pages of which the will is composed, and (2) that the attestation clause does not state that each and every page of the will was signed by the testators in the presence of the witnesses, and that the latter signed the same in the presence of the testators and in the presence of each other.

Upon the issue thus raised, and after hearing the evidence, the court rendered a judgment denying the petition on the ground that the attestation clause did not state that the witnesses signed the will in the presence of the testators, or that both the testators and the witnesses signed the will and each and every page thereof in the presence of each other. In this connection the lower court said:jgc:chanrobles.com.ph

". . . En la clausula de atestiguamiento del testamento en cuestion, se hace constar que los testadores firmaron el testamento en presencia de los tres testigos instrumentales y que éstos firmaron el testamento los unos en presencia de los otros, pero no se hace constar que dichos testigos firmaron el testamento en presencia de los testadores, ni que éstos y aquellos firmaron todas y cada una de las paginas del testamento los primeros en presencia de los segundos y vice-versa.

"En su virtud, se deniega la solicitud en la que se pipde la legalizacion del alegado testamento Exhibit A de Gregorio Pueblo y Carmen Quinto, y se declara que Gregorio Pueblo murio intestado."cralaw virtua1aw library

From that judgment the petitioner appealed and now contends:chanrob1es virtual 1aw library

That the lower court committed an error in denying the application of the petitioner for the probate of the will of the deceased Gregorio Pueblo.

The attestation clause of the will in question. (Exhibit A-1) reads as follows:jgc:chanrobles.com.ph

"Nosotros los que firmamos al final de este testamento, Florentino Joya, Aguedo Soriano y Teodoro Bleza damos fe, de haber visto o presenciado el acto de firmar en esta escritura o testamento de los esposos Gregorio Pueblo y Carmen Quinto; lo firmaron ellos en nuestra presencia, y que nosotros los testigos, lo firmanos en presencia de cada uno de nosotros, hoy 3 de noviembre de 1920. Este testamento esta compuesto de tres fojas
Top of Page