1. PUBLIC SERVICE; CANCELLATION OF CERTIFICATE OF PUBLIC CONVENIENCE. — Although it was provided in the decision on the application in a prior case that for the first violation of the tariff set forth in said decision the Public Service Commission could cancel the applicant’s certificate of public convenience, nevertheless such provision did not oblige the commission to cancel applicant’s certificate upon complaint of the adverse party.

2. ID.; SMALL FINE; DISCRETION OF COMMISSION. — The small fine of P10 imposed by the commission in that case does not constitute an abuse of discretion of the commission.

This is a petition of the Rural Transit Co., Ltd., for the review of the following decision of the Public Service Commission in case No. 32340:jgc:chanrobles.com.ph

"La recurrida lo esta de una infraccion de los terminos de su certificado expedido en el Expediente No. 30532.

"Esta probado que la recurrida opero en mayo 26, 1932, sus automoviles PU-662 y 663 cobrando per capita a los pasajeros por las distancias que cada uno de ellos recorriesen, lo cual es en abierta infraccion de su certificado cuanto que ella esta autorizada a cobrar por hora operando como operada coches PU.

"El testigo que ha declarado por la compañia recurrente, Angel Paulmino, ha aseverado de un modo positivo y cierto que el dia mayo 26, 1932, a las 8.30 de la mañana, inspecciono el automovil de la recurrida PU-662 en el kilometro 126 entre Cabanat